As you have seen the 3900 block is the epicenter of crime
on Chamberlayne Avenue. You can look at the block and see part of what the
problem is: Except for a small office building and the fire station, the
block is solid apartments.
Until March 30, 1999, the police refused us the crime data by
address, but they give out the
calls for service. Unfortunately the latter come as hard copy, not a computer
file. So Capt. Winnie and John spent much of two weeks punching the 1999
Chamberlayne Ave. service calls (2581 of them for the stretch North of
Brookland Parkway, i.e., 3000 block and north) into Excel. They had the entire year, less part of March
20 through March 24 where the printer garbled the sheets. The results
are illuminating.
First, here is a list of the most common of the 2581 service calls:
Item |
Total |
% |
Unk |
476 |
18.4% |
Disorderly |
325 |
12.6% |
Domestic Trouble |
301 |
11.7% |
Silent 911 |
248 |
9.6% |
Noise |
161 |
6.2% |
B&E |
86 |
3.3% |
Vice offense |
64 |
2.5% |
Assault |
63 |
2.4% |
Promiscuous Shooting |
63 |
2.4% |
Missing Person |
59 |
2.3% |
Wanted Person |
58 |
2.2% |
Stolen Vehicle |
56 |
2.2% |
Accident |
54 |
2.1% |
Vandalism |
53 |
2.1% |
Larceny |
52 |
2.0% |
Burglar Alarm |
45 |
1.7% |
Fight |
37 |
1.4% |
Assist EMS |
36 |
1.4% |
Mental Subject |
35 |
1.4% |
Hit & Run |
24 |
0.9% |
Armed Person |
22 |
0.9% |
Missing Juvenile |
18 |
0.7% |
Fire |
16 |
0.6% |
Prowler |
12 |
0.5% |
Traffic Complaint |
12 |
0.5% |
Person Down |
11 |
0.4% |
DOA |
10 |
0.4% |
Smoke inside
structure |
10 |
0.4% |
About a quarter of the calls are for reasons that are not identified.
Another quarter are disorder and domestic disorder. The rest are as you
see. Basically these numbers count the number of times something
provoked somebody to call the cops. Call them a basic measure of
disorder if you will.
Here are the addresses with the most calls. 4930 is the BP
station. The yellow denotes
adult homes; the rest appear to be apartment complexes.
Addr |
Total |
Owner |
3207_11_15 |
154 |
Court Assoc |
3905
to 43 |
145 |
Bellevue
Apartments |
3918_20 |
127 |
Americana Assoc. |
3505 |
115 |
Bernstein
Assoc. |
3210_12 |
95 |
B&N
Assoc./Premier Care |
4301
to 27 |
81 |
Chamberlayne
Investment |
3916 |
75 |
Woelfl |
4801
to 19 |
71 |
Chamberlayne
Investment |
4930 |
60 |
Southern
Retailers |
3401 |
58 |
DLM Corp |
3206 |
55 |
Page |
3006 |
47 |
Court Assoc |
3603_5 |
39 |
Zacharias |
3406 |
36 |
Court Assoc |
3813 |
35 |
Bellevue
Apartments |
3810 |
34 |
Beekne Inv. Co. |
Note that the 3207-11-15 complex had more calls than the long block of the
Bellevue Gardens in the 3900 block.
The 3900 block, which is adjacent to our neighborhood, is a story in its
own. The problems are not evenly distributed.
We see the same thing on either side of the street. On the East, the big Bellevue Gardens complex
has hotspots that
clearly need attention:
Address |
Total |
3905 |
10 |
3907 |
13 |
3909 |
6 |
3911 |
5 |
3913 |
2 |
3915 |
5 |
3917 |
5 |
3919 |
6 |
3921 |
7 |
3923 |
3 |
3925 |
5 |
3927 |
4 |
3929 |
4 |
3931 |
5 |
3933 |
5 |
3935 |
37 |
3937 |
4 |
3939 |
3 |
3941 |
2 |
3943 |
14 |
The pie chart makes the case even more clearly:
Thus we see that four of the twenty addresses in the Bellevue Gardens are
generating over half the police calls. This plainly is a management
issue.
The west side of the 3900 Block is even more interesting:
Abbey Square (3918-20) and the Redwoods (3916) are generating 61% of the
calls for service. The complexes farther toward Laburnum Ave. are doing
much better. We think it is time to find
out what some landlords are doing right and get it done everywhere on
Chamberlayne.
Back at 3207-11-15 there is some Bad Stuff, including what looks like probable
cause for a wall-to-wall fire inspection:
Item |
Total |
Unk |
26 |
Domestic
Trouble |
23 |
Disorderly |
15 |
Noise |
11 |
Silent
911 |
11 |
Stolen
Vehicle |
9 |
Vandalism |
8 |
Wanted
Person |
7 |
B&E |
6 |
Assault |
5 |
Recovered
Vehicle |
3 |
Armed
Person |
2 |
Gas
Leak |
2 |
Hit
& Run |
2 |
Serve
Warrant |
2 |
Smoke
inside structure |
2 |
Suspicious
vehicle |
2 |
Vice
offense |
2 |
Apartment
Fire |
1 |
Assist
EMS |
1 |
Assist
Landlord |
1 |
Assist
w Vehicle |
1 |
Fire |
1 |
Fire |
1 |
Found
Property |
1 |
Holding
Person |
1 |
Indecent
Exposure |
1 |
Juvenile |
1 |
Kitchen
Fire |
1 |
Mail
taken from mailbox |
1 |
Missing
Person |
1 |
Person
Down |
1 |
Promiscuous
Shooting |
1 |
Smoke
Alarm |
1 |
3207-11-15 may have improved a bit over the year
but Abbey Square was getting worse
As we mentioned above, even after lots of police attention, heavy duty
efforts by the neighborhood (ask Meg Lawrence or Norma Murdoch-Kitt if you
want to hear an awful story), and Operation Squalor, the Redwood Apts at 3916
still are a problem with 75 calls.
The Bellevue experience
suggests that the focus on the lawbreakers is the wrong approach and the
landlord is the key to the solution. Arresting a drug dealer, for
example, just means the rest of us pay to feed and house him in jail while
another pops up before you can say "drug dealer!" It is the
landlord who can be selective about the tenants, evict the drug dealers, and
enforce the rules. If the landlord wants the place clean, it will be
clean. See the comments by one
landlord for some thoughts on this subject.
Our Safety Committee is targeting these problems: Make a worst-first list, work with the neighborhoods, and
use all the civil, criminal, and bureaucratic tools.
Stay tuned.
In the meantime we now have the offense data by
address.
NOTE ADDED ON APRIL 23 2000: At
the BCA meeting on April 18 Capt. Kiniry showed up with a copy of the arrest
reports for Chamberlayne Avenue and a list of calls for service based on
vice complaints. The arrest
reports tell a tale of concentrated problems at the Redwood and Abbey
Square. The vice complaints tell a similar story. Here are the
1999 vice calls on Chamberlayne north of Brookland Park showing totals by
address for the high density addresses, and % of the 64 total.
Address |
Total |
% |
3900B
|
10 |
15.6% |
3920 |
9 |
14.1% |
3918 |
5 |
7.8% |
3006 |
3 |
4.7% |
3916 |
3 |
4.7% |
4904 |
3 |
4.7% |
3211 |
2 |
3.1% |
3816 |
2 |
3.1% |
3933 |
2 |
3.1% |
3935 |
2 |
3.1% |
4313 |
2 |
3.1% |
4802 |
2 |
3.1% |
3200B
|
2 |
3.1% |
Note: We think the "3900B" entry denotes calls for the
3900 block.